I can't believe this?

Comments

[this is good]
Okay this is for real. The guy asking the questions is an Australian from the show "Chasers War on Everything". The people they are asking are NOT actors. Hopefully there were many that got some of the answers right and they just didn't show us them.

I didn't think it was funny at all, they were going to mistakenly blow my country up thinking it was Iran!!!!!!!!!!

Hello - Iran is up people not "down under" and Iran is surround by other countries not a single island. Middle East, not South Pacific.

I think that Chezz - C'Tack! is right.

"there were many that got some of the answers right and they just didn't show us them."

I have saw the analogous problem in Taiwan's mediums.

Yes. I have seen another video that shows 25 out 100 who were questioned could not locate the USA on the map Of course, you already saw the Miss South Carolina video on this blog where my students gave some answers as to why this may be the case. I think 25% is quite a high figure for a so called first-world country. Glad you had some fun. Come again.

I can believe it! If someone came to my country (South Africa) and asked random people on the street the same questions, I'm sure

Sorry, I don't think my entire comment came through..I'm new to Vox. In short I think that it's unfair to make broad generalisations like "All Americans are stupid" and I think that it's a good discussion base base for topics like; media ownership, education in the capitilist system etc... If not anything, a look at answering questions under pressure!

I could only dig up these, though I am sure there is something that compares public opinion on general affairs from various countries.

Young Americans lack basic global knowledge: National Geographic Society (May 2nd 2006)

Geography: Greek to Young Americans (CNN, May 4th 2006)

Sam, I have to disagree about your guess concerning Azanian people's knowledge. Of course, generalisations are not helpful, neither is guesswork. It certainly depends on socio-economic conditions and education. And there are differences from one place to another, due to factors such as these and the level of maturity of systems of democracy. I would hazard a guess anyway, that if one were to chose areas that were similar to those featured here, I think you would struggle to get so many silly answers in Azania. Yes, the video was probably edited to show only the silly answers, but 20% is an awfully high level of ignorance concerning where the USA is on the map (or was that Iraq).

This is perhaps off the point, though it ties in with education. An excerpt from USA today concerning illiteracy:

Sometimes dumb sounds cute: Sixty percent of Americans can't name five of the Ten Commandments, and 50% of high school seniors think Sodom and Gomorrah were married.

Laugh or cry? It's your choice.

Doorae, I'm a little confused as to why you are referring to my country as Azania. The name was orginally used to refer to people originating from the North Western parts of Africa.... The name Azania has been used in a South African context during the Apartheid era as a reactionary statement againest the oppressive ruling party etc etc..but I'm sure you are familiar with the history and origins of the word. I know we're talking semiotics here but I find your use of the word slightly inappropriate. That aside, As an Educator I understand that people learn and retain information that they feel applies to them directly or has some consequential value to them. So although the ignorance is unacceptable it is also understandable.

Sorry one more thing..my "guess" seems fair enough considering the amount of people that are iliterate. Also remember Thomas that I too am from South Africa and from a community far more integrated that what you imagine...my "guess" is as good as yours.
I use the name Azania because, when Azanians achieve political and economic independance, they will choose this name instead of continuing to use the colonial and nationalist name. The name south Africa is an inappropriate name because of it's colonial roots. As you know the barbaric cutting up of the continent by European imperialists resulted in much of the political turmoil we now see. Regions of power were melted into new "countries". The words "south Africa" have more to do with "directions" or "location" than a national identity. Adopting a name is about claiming an identity.

So what is our identity? The name Azania had its origins in EASTERN Africa (the areas now known as Somalia and Sudan and the islands off the East African coast). It was later used by Arab merchants to refer to the entire continent. As you know, the people of the Azanian continent were contributing to mathematics, medicine and art and the continent was the centre of learning, a very long time before Europe crawled out of it's "dark age". In early Azanian literature, the continent of Europe was know as a dark, miserable place where the sounds of groans and shouts could be heard as the Africans sailed the Mediteranean. Because of the early recorded references to the learning and cultural center of the world as "Azania" I see little reason it should offend any Africans when we eventually adopt this name. In fact, it would be an honor if Africans accepted this name for our country, as opposed to it being used for a united Africa instead. It is more than appropriate and well known in reference to the the place now known as "south Africa".

On the second point about literacy.. One would have to define literacy in order to continue this debate. I am still of the opinion that more Azanians are familiar with world geography than Americans are. For one, our education prgrams are superior even though we are poorly funded and our graduates have fewer opportunities than their American counterparts. Teh reason Americans are unfamiliar with the world is a political phenomenon and (as you suggested) perhaps due to the lack of unbiased and high quality media organisations in the USA. A result of propaganda and the resulting "neo-colonial" mind set, perhaps.

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in

About Me

Doorae
Korea, Republic of
The natural alternative school
Yahoo!:
doorae_english@yahoo.co.uk

My Groups

Archives

  • Powered by Vox